Back Attorneys: Benefis destroyed evidence - ABC FOX Montana Local News, Weather, Sports KTMF | KWYB

Back Attorneys: Benefis destroyed evidence

Posted: Updated:

As we first reported on kfbb.com, the case surrounding Belt Football Player Robert Back and Benefis Health System was focused on the legal responsibility of Athletic Trainer Jessica Hansen,  in the game that ultimately lead to Back being deemed a quadriplegic.


As of Friday, we're learning a new legal battle is brewing over whether or not Benefis purposefully destroyed evidence.

To catch up on the timeline of this case: in September of 2014, Robert Back collapsed after halftime on the football field doctors later determined the full extent of his injuries as we know them today.

In July of 2015, attorneys alerted Benefis Health System that they were planning to file suit, and they should begin preserving all evidence.

The following March, the Back family did file suit, claiming negligence from several parties.

When Benefis was informed of the lawsuit, they were expected to keep and file all correspondence relating to the case. But now, attorneys for the Back family allege not only did Benefis not hand over important evidence, they destroyed it. And now there's an email to prove it.

The email in question is from September 11th, 2014, in which athletic trainer Jessica Hansen tells Belt football coach Jeff Graham, Robert Back is
ok to play concussion wise.

Despite the email coming from Hansen, a Benefis employee, Benefis never turned the email in as evidence. It wasn't until legal counsel for the Back family produced the email last year, with help from the Belt School District, that it came to light Hansen explicitly said Robert was okay to play from a concussion standpoint.

Court documents lay out Benefis' reasoning,  being that they only conducted a search limited to emails containing  Robert Back. Thats how the email slipped through the cracks. In turn, attorneys for Benefis are questioning the Back family saying if they knew about the email all along, why didn't *they bring it forward to submit as evidence?

And that's not all
Back's attorneys also claim there could be a number of unknown emails, texts, and messages regarding the events leading up to Back's injury, which now, we will never know.

As of December 2017, Back's attorneys are requesting sanctions against Benefis relating to the
Spoliation of Evidence.  Judge John Kutzman has yet to make a decision on those sanctions.  Trial is scheduled for March 5th.


Correction, Jan. 15th, 2017: A previous version of this article stated Shannon Back produced the email in which Hansen stated Robert was “ok concussion wise.” While the details of the email and it’s discovery were outlined in Mrs. Back’s discovery response, Shannon Back herself never personally knew of or saw the email until it was presented by her legal counsel, with help from the Belt School District’s legal counsel.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Update: Fatal crashed reported in Pondera County

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 4:35 PM EST2018-01-16 21:35:14 GMT
    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:35 PM EST2018-01-19 00:35:27 GMT

    Montana Highway Patrol responded to a fatal vehicle accident Tuesday morning in Pondera County near the Heart Butte area. The accident took place on Heart Butte Road right in front of the U.S. Postal Office. The call came in over dispatch about 5:30 a.m. and took MHP troopers almost two hours to respond to the scene. Right now it is unclear what caused the accident or if anyone else was hurt or killed. We are working to find out more details.

    Montana Highway Patrol responded to a fatal vehicle accident Tuesday morning in Pondera County near the Heart Butte area. The accident took place on Heart Butte Road right in front of the U.S. Postal Office. The call came in over dispatch about 5:30 a.m. and took MHP troopers almost two hours to respond to the scene. Right now it is unclear what caused the accident or if anyone else was hurt or killed. We are working to find out more details.

  • Great Falls women take to the streets for Women's March

    Great Falls women take to the streets for Women's March

    Saturday, January 20 2018 7:16 PM EST2018-01-21 00:16:13 GMT
    Saturday, January 20 2018 7:16 PM EST2018-01-21 00:16:13 GMT
    Millions of women gathered all over the county including right here in Great Falls all for one cause and that's women's right Over 300 hundred women gathered at Gibson Park in what is called the "March for Democracy." Jerry Jennings, coordinator for Great Falls Rising said this march represents the rise of diversity, equal rights and justice for all.  One woman in Great Falls this is the second march she has attended and said shes marches on behalf of women who can't...
    Millions of women gathered all over the county including right here in Great Falls all for one cause and that's women's right Over 300 hundred women gathered at Gibson Park in what is called the "March for Democracy." Jerry Jennings, coordinator for Great Falls Rising said this march represents the rise of diversity, equal rights and justice for all.  One woman in Great Falls this is the second march she has attended and said shes marches on behalf of women who can't...
  • Montana men arrested in Idaho following road rage incident

    Montana men arrested in Idaho following road rage incident

    Saturday, January 20 2018 1:42 PM EST2018-01-20 18:42:34 GMT
    Authorities in northern Idaho say two Montana men have been taken into custody following a road rage incident that included shots fired.
    Authorities in northern Idaho say two Montana men have been taken into custody following a road rage incident that included shots fired.
  • Malmstrom receives new weapon to arsenal

    Malmstrom receives new weapon to arsenal

    Friday, January 19 2018 8:05 PM EST2018-01-20 01:05:35 GMT
    Friday, January 19 2018 8:05 PM EST2018-01-20 01:05:35 GMT
    It's the job of thousands of people to keep Malmstrom Air Force Base safe but there are a few jobs that just can't be done by humans. With that Malstrom has added a new k-9 to there arsenal. His name is Kay is the newest member of the 341st Security Forces Squadron and this is also his first duty job. His handler, Senior Airmen Ben Huntley, said this his third dog he ever handled and is extremely lucky to have added such a great dog on the team
    It's the job of thousands of people to keep Malmstrom Air Force Base safe but there are a few jobs that just can't be done by humans. With that Malstrom has added a new k-9 to there arsenal. His name is Kay is the newest member of the 341st Security Forces Squadron and this is also his first duty job. His handler, Senior Airmen Ben Huntley, said this his third dog he ever handled and is extremely lucky to have added such a great dog on the team
  • Class is in session

    Class is in session

    Friday, January 19 2018 8:38 PM EST2018-01-20 01:38:22 GMT
    Friday, January 19 2018 8:38 PM EST2018-01-20 01:38:22 GMT

    Following a story we first brought to you last summer the first ever school for children with autism in Montana is finally able to open their doors.  Sense-Ability INC.

    Following a story we first brought to you last summer the first ever school for children with autism in Montana is finally able to open their doors.  Sense-Ability INC.

  • Government shutting down amid partisan standoff

    Government shutting down amid partisan standoff

    Friday, January 19 2018 10:53 PM EST2018-01-20 03:53:04 GMT
    Saturday, January 20 2018 12:16 AM EST2018-01-20 05:16:04 GMT

    The U.S. government shut down at midnight after Congress failed to resolve a partisan standoff over immigration and spending.

    The U.S. government shut down at midnight after Congress failed to resolve a partisan standoff over immigration and spending.

  • Benefis accreditation has better chance of retaining quality care in Montana

    Benefis accreditation has better chance of retaining quality care in Montana

    Friday, January 5 2018 8:09 PM EST2018-01-06 01:09:20 GMT
    Friday, January 5 2018 8:09 PM EST2018-01-06 01:09:20 GMT
    Montana along with Idaho, Wyoming and the Dakota's were the only states lacking accredited medical schools until now.  The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education awarded Benefis with sponsorship back in December to be able to provide students with medical residency. Benefis says this gives them the opportunity to teach and develop physicians who want to be in Montana. John Goodnow, CEO of Benefis, said this programs has been in the works for about 3 years and is ho...
    Montana along with Idaho, Wyoming and the Dakota's were the only states lacking accredited medical schools until now.  The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education awarded Benefis with sponsorship back in December to be able to provide students with medical residency. Benefis says this gives them the opportunity to teach and develop physicians who want to be in Montana. John Goodnow, CEO of Benefis, said this programs has been in the works for about 3 years and is ho...
  • Lavina to become Montana's smallest town with a brewery

    Lavina to become Montana's smallest town with a brewery

    Friday, January 19 2018 10:37 AM EST2018-01-19 15:37:32 GMT
    Friday, January 19 2018 10:40 AM EST2018-01-19 15:40:15 GMT

    Good news for Montanans seeking out another brew!

    Good news for Montanans seeking out another brew!

  • NewsMore>>

  • Despite threats, Capitol workers feel safe

    Despite threats, Capitol workers feel safe

    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:37 PM EST2018-01-19 00:37:48 GMT
    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:37 PM EST2018-01-19 00:37:48 GMT
    HELENA, Mont.- A major threat to the state capitol as a man is taken into custody after telling police he was planning to "shoot up" the building.  Police say he may have been on his way to the capitol when he was caught. On Tuesday, the man told officers he planned to shoot up the Capitol the next day. Teams in Bozeman and Helena worked together to identify the suspect-- a 40-year-old Belgrade man. Yesterday they learned he had left Belgrade on his way to Helena. H...
    HELENA, Mont.- A major threat to the state capitol as a man is taken into custody after telling police he was planning to "shoot up" the building.  Police say he may have been on his way to the capitol when he was caught. On Tuesday, the man told officers he planned to shoot up the Capitol the next day. Teams in Bozeman and Helena worked together to identify the suspect-- a 40-year-old Belgrade man. Yesterday they learned he had left Belgrade on his way to Helena. H...
  • Update: Fatal crashed reported in Pondera County

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 4:35 PM EST2018-01-16 21:35:14 GMT
    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:35 PM EST2018-01-19 00:35:27 GMT

    Montana Highway Patrol responded to a fatal vehicle accident Tuesday morning in Pondera County near the Heart Butte area. The accident took place on Heart Butte Road right in front of the U.S. Postal Office. The call came in over dispatch about 5:30 a.m. and took MHP troopers almost two hours to respond to the scene. Right now it is unclear what caused the accident or if anyone else was hurt or killed. We are working to find out more details.

    Montana Highway Patrol responded to a fatal vehicle accident Tuesday morning in Pondera County near the Heart Butte area. The accident took place on Heart Butte Road right in front of the U.S. Postal Office. The call came in over dispatch about 5:30 a.m. and took MHP troopers almost two hours to respond to the scene. Right now it is unclear what caused the accident or if anyone else was hurt or killed. We are working to find out more details.

  • MAGIE expo is here in the Electric City

    MAGIE expo is here in the Electric City

    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:16 PM EST2018-01-19 00:16:39 GMT
    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:16 PM EST2018-01-19 00:16:39 GMT
    Its that time of year Again for those who are looking to buy that new tractor they have been eying all year or just to get some financial advice for anything Ag-related and MAGIE is the place to be. Thursday kicked off the event at the Montana Expo Park is where you can talk to over 300 vendors selling everything from handheld tools all the way to monster truck sized tractors. This year is the opportunity for farmers, ranchers or just people who love agriculture, to learn about the n...
    Its that time of year Again for those who are looking to buy that new tractor they have been eying all year or just to get some financial advice for anything Ag-related and MAGIE is the place to be. Thursday kicked off the event at the Montana Expo Park is where you can talk to over 300 vendors selling everything from handheld tools all the way to monster truck sized tractors. This year is the opportunity for farmers, ranchers or just people who love agriculture, to learn about the n...
  • Montana's little learners

    Montana's little learners

    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:05 PM EST2018-01-19 00:05:26 GMT
    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:05 PM EST2018-01-19 00:05:26 GMT

    Your child's preschool education could be getting a big boost thanks to the Governor. This week Bullock announced more funding for high-quality preschool. Over $1.3 Million in supplemental funding is going towards more at risk Montana children.

    Your child's preschool education could be getting a big boost thanks to the Governor. This week Bullock announced more funding for high-quality preschool. Over $1.3 Million in supplemental funding is going towards more at risk Montana children.

  • New Park District public hearing set

    New Park District public hearing set

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 11:35 PM EST2018-01-17 04:35:07 GMT
    Wednesday, January 17 2018 12:45 AM EST2018-01-17 05:45:12 GMT

    The Great Falls City Commission is releasing an updated proposal for a park district. This new version comes after the first proposal did not make it past voters last year. The biggest change is the amount of money the city is asking for. Instead of 2.27 million dollars from the taxpayers, it will be 1.5million dollars. Meaning the maximum property owners will pay in a year would be roughly 22 dollars a year, or less than 2 dollars a month. The parks department says this proposal n...

    The Great Falls City Commission is releasing an updated proposal for a park district. This new version comes after the first proposal did not make it past voters last year. The biggest change is the amount of money the city is asking for. Instead of 2.27 million dollars from the taxpayers, it will be 1.5million dollars. Meaning the maximum property owners will pay in a year would be roughly 22 dollars a year, or less than 2 dollars a month. The parks department says this proposal n...

  • Man trying to buy tires arrested for forgery

    Man trying to buy tires arrested for forgery

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 9:28 PM EST2018-01-17 02:28:45 GMT
    Tuesday, January 16 2018 9:28 PM EST2018-01-17 02:28:45 GMT

    Troy Allan Nelson has been arrested for Forgery and Elder/Persons With Developmental Disabilities Abuse after allegedly trying to buy tires with an 86 year old woman's check. 

    Troy Allan Nelson has been arrested for Forgery and Elder/Persons With Developmental Disabilities Abuse after allegedly trying to buy tires with an 86 year old woman's check. 

  • Update: One man is in custody after ATM theft

    Update: One man is in custody after ATM theft

    Monday, January 8 2018 7:51 PM EST2018-01-09 00:51:57 GMT
    Tuesday, January 16 2018 7:51 PM EST2018-01-17 00:51:19 GMT


    Police say they have several leads and are working hard to find the criminals and get the machine back to its rightful owner, but one patron said he doesn't think they were after the cash, but instead the pin numbers stored inside that machine, which could lead to a bigger problem for the bar and grille.
     

    The suspects got away after leading officers with the Lewis and Clark county Sheriff's Department on a dangerous chase along Lincoln Road after they broke into the Causeway Chalet and stole the bar's ATM.

  • New improvements planned for Historic 10th Street Bridge

    New improvements planned for Historic 10th Street Bridge

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 7:20 PM EST2018-01-17 00:20:43 GMT
    Tuesday, January 16 2018 7:44 PM EST2018-01-17 00:44:56 GMT

    Preservation Cascade Inc. has big plans for the Historic 10th Street Bridge, but they need your help and support! Those plans include a complete trail across the Bridge by 2020, installing railings, and incorporating the River’s Edge Trail with the Historic Bridge. To help out, start by attending the upcoming annual meeting, taking place Monday, January 22nd at 7:00pm in the Civic Center Gibson Room. After a brief business meeting, folks can enjoy talks by Public Works Directo...

    Preservation Cascade Inc. has big plans for the Historic 10th Street Bridge, but they need your help and support! Those plans include a complete trail across the Bridge by 2020, installing railings, and incorporating the River’s Edge Trail with the Historic Bridge. To help out, start by attending the upcoming annual meeting, taking place Monday, January 22nd at 7:00pm in the Civic Center Gibson Room. After a brief business meeting, folks can enjoy talks by Public Works Directo...

Powered by Frankly

Features

  • More Features
  • Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 Cowles Montana Media. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.