Back Attorneys: Benefis destroyed evidence - ABC FOX Montana Local News, Weather, Sports KTMF | KWYB

Back Attorneys: Benefis destroyed evidence

UPDATE: Judge John Kutzman has denied the Plaintiffs' spoliation motion.

Court documents filed Friday, February 16th state that while Benefis may have been "negligent," they were not necessarily "willful." The 36-page document goes on to state the "Plaintiffs cite no legal authority to support inferring willful spoliation from the entire pattern of Benefis's mistakes in discovery." Documents conclude by stating in part, "Ultimately the court cannot say without indulging in speculation that the plaintiffs have been deprived of evidence that would have made their case better than it is now."


As we first reported on kfbb.com, the case surrounding Belt Football Player Robert Back and Benefis Health System was focused on the legal responsibility of Athletic Trainer Jessica Hansen, in the game that ultimately led to Back suffering a brain injury and becoming a quadriplegic.

A new legal battle is brewing over whether or not Benefis purposefully destroyed evidence.

To catch up on the timeline of this case: in September of 2014, Robert Back collapsed after halftime on the football field doctors later determined the full extent of his injuries as we know them today.

In July of 2015, attorneys alerted Benefis Health System that they were planning to file suit, and they should begin preserving all evidence.

The following March, the Back family did file suit, claiming negligence from several parties.

When Benefis was informed of the lawsuit, they were expected to keep and file all correspondence relating to the case. But now, attorneys for the Back family allege not only did Benefis not hand over important evidence, they destroyed it. And now there's an email to prove it.

The email in question is from September 11th, 2014, in which athletic trainer Jessica Hansen tells Belt football coach Jeff Graham, Robert Back is
ok to play concussion wise.

Despite the email coming from Hansen, a Benefis employee, Benefis never turned the email in as evidence. It wasn't until legal counsel for the Back family produced the email last year, with help from the Belt School District, that it came to light Hansen explicitly said Robert was okay to play from a concussion standpoint.

Court documents lay out Benefis' reasoning,  being that they only conducted a search limited to emails containing  Robert Back. Thats how the email slipped through the cracks. In turn, attorneys for Benefis are questioning the Back family saying if they knew about the email all along, why didn't *they bring it forward to submit as evidence?

And that's not all
Back's attorneys also claim there could be a number of unknown emails, texts, and messages regarding the events leading up to Back's injury, which now, we will never know.

As of December 2017, Back's attorneys are requesting sanctions against Benefis relating to the
Spoliation of Evidence.  Judge John Kutzman has yet to make a decision on those sanctions.  Trial is scheduled for March 5.


Correction, Jan. 15th, 2017: A previous version of this article stated Shannon Back produced the email in which Hansen stated Robert was “ok concussion wise.” While the details of the email and its discovery were outlined in Mrs. Back’s discovery response, Shannon Back herself never personally knew of or saw the email until it was presented by her legal counsel, with help from the Belt School District’s legal counsel.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • City budget passes, Natatorium will close

    City budget passes, Natatorium will close

    Tuesday, July 17 2018 11:39 PM EDT2018-07-18 03:39:34 GMT
    Tuesday, July 17 2018 11:39 PM EDT2018-07-18 03:39:34 GMT

    The city commission passed the Great Falls annual $117.9 million city budget on Tuesday, with a lot of discussion on what the future holds. 

    The city commission passed the Great Falls annual $117.9 million city budget on Tuesday, with a lot of discussion on what the future holds. 

  • GFPD needs the public help to find Tamara "Tammy" Goff

    GFPD needs the public help to find Tamara "Tammy" Goff

    Friday, July 13 2018 3:23 PM EDT2018-07-13 19:23:05 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 5:37 PM EDT2018-07-20 21:37:44 GMT

    Just an hour ago the Great Falls Police Department issued a community alert for a missing person. The missing person's name is Tamara "Tammy" Goff. She was last seen leaving her residence in the 2100 block of 7th Ave North, in a 2008 black Chevrolet Colorado (MT plate 293204A), on July 12, 2018, at approximately 7am.  Tammy was said to be headed to the south end of Great Falls with her dog “Sadie”, a German Shepherd mix.  If you have any information a...

    Just an hour ago the Great Falls Police Department issued a community alert for a missing person. The missing person's name is Tamara "Tammy" Goff. She was last seen leaving her residence in the 2100 block of 7th Ave North, in a 2008 black Chevrolet Colorado (MT plate 293204A), on July 12, 2018, at approximately 7am.  Tammy was said to be headed to the south end of Great Falls with her dog “Sadie”, a German Shepherd mix.  If you have any information a...

  • 22-year-old Sandpoint man dies in Clayton 395 crash

    22-year-old Sandpoint man dies in Clayton 395 crash

    Saturday, July 21 2018 1:58 AM EDT2018-07-21 05:58:53 GMT

    STEVENS COUNTY, Wash. - Washington State Patrols responded to a fatal crash in Stevens County Friday evening. On SR-395 in Clayton near Mile Post 185, a vehicle crossed the center line and crashed head on with another car, killing the driver. The causing driver who was transported to the hospital is in custody for vehicular homicide. There were no other occupants of either vehicle. 

    STEVENS COUNTY, Wash. - Washington State Patrols responded to a fatal crash in Stevens County Friday evening. On SR-395 in Clayton near Mile Post 185, a vehicle crossed the center line and crashed head on with another car, killing the driver. The causing driver who was transported to the hospital is in custody for vehicular homicide. There were no other occupants of either vehicle. 

  • "Badly decomposed" body pulled from Clark Fork River

    "Badly decomposed" body pulled from Clark Fork River

    Friday, July 20 2018 3:56 PM EDT2018-07-20 19:56:28 GMT
    Clark Fork on May 18 (file photo)Clark Fork on May 18 (file photo)
    Clark Fork on May 18 (file photo)Clark Fork on May 18 (file photo)

    Law enforcement officials are trying to determine the identity of a body pulled from the Clark Fork river yesterday. 

    Law enforcement officials are trying to determine the identity of a body pulled from the Clark Fork river yesterday. 

  • Small wildfire burning south of Big Sky

    Small wildfire burning south of Big Sky

    Saturday, July 21 2018 3:36 PM EDT2018-07-21 19:36:15 GMT
    Saturday, July 21 2018 4:57 PM EDT2018-07-21 20:57:47 GMT

    A small, lighting-caused wildfire is burning south of Big Sky. 

    A small, lighting-caused wildfire is burning south of Big Sky. 

  • Car chase starts in Sweet Grass County and ends in Park County

    Car chase starts in Sweet Grass County and ends in Park County

    Friday, July 20 2018 1:20 AM EDT2018-07-20 05:20:43 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 1:20 AM EDT2018-07-20 05:20:43 GMT

    Montana Highway Patrol Sergeant Joshua Brown confirmed a high speed chase started around 4:30 Thursday afternoon in Sweet Grass County and ultimately ending in Park County.  

    Montana Highway Patrol Sergeant Joshua Brown confirmed a high speed chase started around 4:30 Thursday afternoon in Sweet Grass County and ultimately ending in Park County.  

  • Hikers find decomposed body near Gates of the Mountain

    Hikers find decomposed body near Gates of the Mountain

    Saturday, July 21 2018 1:36 PM EDT2018-07-21 17:36:35 GMT
    Saturday, July 21 2018 6:16 PM EDT2018-07-21 22:16:03 GMT

    Lewis and Clark County sheriff's office is investigating a death after two hikers found a body near Gates of the Mountain Friday evening. Sheriff Leo Dutton tells us the body was found to the north of gates of the mountains. Dutton said they can't determine the gender because the body was so badly decomposed. He added the body was probably out here for a week or more and it is unclear of the age of the person. Search and rescue crews had to be deployed to retrieve the body because of...

    Lewis and Clark County sheriff's office is investigating a death after two hikers found a body near Gates of the Mountain Friday evening. Sheriff Leo Dutton tells us the body was found to the north of gates of the mountains. Dutton said they can't determine the gender because the body was so badly decomposed. He added the body was probably out here for a week or more and it is unclear of the age of the person. Search and rescue crews had to be deployed to retrieve the body because of...

  • UPDATE: Sheriff releases more information on shooting

    UPDATE: Sheriff releases more information on shooting

    Wednesday, July 18 2018 10:19 PM EDT2018-07-19 02:19:39 GMT
    Thursday, July 19 2018 3:31 PM EDT2018-07-19 19:31:13 GMT

    Sun Prairie, MT - Cascade County Sheriff Bob Edwards has confirmed with KFBB that one person was shot in Sun Prairie on Washington Boulevard. 

    Sun Prairie, MT - Cascade County Sheriff Bob Edwards has confirmed with KFBB that one person was shot in Sun Prairie on Washington Boulevard. 

  • NewsMore>>

  • Hikers find decomposed body near Gates of the Mountain

    Hikers find decomposed body near Gates of the Mountain

    Saturday, July 21 2018 1:36 PM EDT2018-07-21 17:36:35 GMT
    Saturday, July 21 2018 6:16 PM EDT2018-07-21 22:16:03 GMT

    Lewis and Clark County sheriff's office is investigating a death after two hikers found a body near Gates of the Mountain Friday evening. Sheriff Leo Dutton tells us the body was found to the north of gates of the mountains. Dutton said they can't determine the gender because the body was so badly decomposed. He added the body was probably out here for a week or more and it is unclear of the age of the person. Search and rescue crews had to be deployed to retrieve the body because of...

    Lewis and Clark County sheriff's office is investigating a death after two hikers found a body near Gates of the Mountain Friday evening. Sheriff Leo Dutton tells us the body was found to the north of gates of the mountains. Dutton said they can't determine the gender because the body was so badly decomposed. He added the body was probably out here for a week or more and it is unclear of the age of the person. Search and rescue crews had to be deployed to retrieve the body because of...

  • Small wildfire burning south of Big Sky

    Small wildfire burning south of Big Sky

    Saturday, July 21 2018 3:36 PM EDT2018-07-21 19:36:15 GMT
    Saturday, July 21 2018 4:57 PM EDT2018-07-21 20:57:47 GMT

    A small, lighting-caused wildfire is burning south of Big Sky. 

    A small, lighting-caused wildfire is burning south of Big Sky. 

  • Montana Treasure: Iris the Osprey and nest cam

    Montana Treasure: Iris the Osprey and nest cam

    Monday, July 16 2018 7:57 PM EDT2018-07-16 23:57:42 GMT

    MISSOULA - One Montana mom is known around the world. She only lives in the state in the summer, and her home is streamed online 24 hours a day.

    MISSOULA - One Montana mom is known around the world. She only lives in the state in the summer, and her home is streamed online 24 hours a day.

  • 7,000 stolen dog tags

    7,000 stolen dog tags

    Monday, July 16 2018 9:17 PM EDT2018-07-17 01:17:00 GMT
    Monday, July 16 2018 9:17 PM EDT2018-07-17 01:17:00 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- For almost two weeks, the Cascade County Sheriff’s Office has been searching for any signs of a stolen military bag taken on the Fourth of July. 

    GREAT FALLS- For almost two weeks, the Cascade County Sheriff’s Office has been searching for any signs of a stolen military bag taken on the Fourth of July. 

  • Two dead in Helena, investigation underway

    Two dead in Helena, investigation underway

    Monday, July 16 2018 2:21 PM EDT2018-07-16 18:21:37 GMT
    Monday, July 16 2018 7:22 PM EDT2018-07-16 23:22:05 GMT

    The Helena police department is investigating after two bodies were discovered inside a home along Hannaford Street. According to Lieutenant Jayson Zander, police were called to the scene around 10 a.m. Monday. When they arrived, they found the bodies of a man and a woman. 

    The Helena police department is investigating after two bodies were discovered inside a home along Hannaford Street. According to Lieutenant Jayson Zander, police were called to the scene around 10 a.m. Monday. When they arrived, they found the bodies of a man and a woman. 

  • Drunk driver crashes going 100 MPH on I-15

    Drunk driver crashes going 100 MPH on I-15

    Sunday, July 15 2018 7:42 PM EDT2018-07-15 23:42:29 GMT
    Sunday, July 15 2018 7:44 PM EDT2018-07-15 23:44:32 GMT

     Witnesses say the driver was traveling over 100 MPH and tried to light a cigarette, causing her car to go over the median and roll over.

     Witnesses say the driver was traveling over 100 MPH and tried to light a cigarette, causing her car to go over the median and roll over.

  • Driver not wearing helmet in fatal Lolo crash

    Driver not wearing helmet in fatal Lolo crash

    Sunday, July 15 2018 6:39 PM EDT2018-07-15 22:39:02 GMT
    Sunday, July 15 2018 6:39 PM EDT2018-07-15 22:39:02 GMT

    According to Montana Highway Patrol, a 20-year-old Missoula man is dead after crashing his motorcycle just after 8:00 pm Friday. The accident happened on US Highway 93 southbound near Lolo. According to troopers, the driver failed to negotiate his Harley Davidson at a lefthand curve, and struck the concrete barrier. 

    According to Montana Highway Patrol, a 20-year-old Missoula man is dead after crashing his motorcycle just after 8:00 pm Friday. The accident happened on US Highway 93 southbound near Lolo. According to troopers, the driver failed to negotiate his Harley Davidson at a lefthand curve, and struck the concrete barrier. 

  • Bands travel across country to perform in Butte

    Bands travel across country to perform in Butte

    Saturday, July 14 2018 8:06 PM EDT2018-07-15 00:06:43 GMT
    Saturday, July 14 2018 8:11 PM EDT2018-07-15 00:11:10 GMT

    In Butte, day two of the Montana Folk Fest got underway Saturday afternoon. Despite the hot sun, people turned out in crowds to listen to music and eat good food. One band came all the way from New York to perform for the Mining City. And the heat... didn't slow anyone down.  "We are more grateful than you can imagine to be here, and it just reminds us that doing music despite all of the hardship is so valuable and so important and we are thrilled to be doing it for al...

    In Butte, day two of the Montana Folk Fest got underway Saturday afternoon. Despite the hot sun, people turned out in crowds to listen to music and eat good food. One band came all the way from New York to perform for the Mining City. And the heat... didn't slow anyone down.  "We are more grateful than you can imagine to be here, and it just reminds us that doing music despite all of the hardship is so valuable and so important and we are thrilled to be doing it for al...

Powered by Frankly

Features

  • More Features
  • Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 Cowles Montana Media. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.