Back Attorneys: Benefis destroyed evidence - ABC FOX Montana Local News, Weather, Sports KTMF | KWYB

Back Attorneys: Benefis destroyed evidence

UPDATE: Judge John Kutzman has denied the Plaintiffs' spoliation motion.

Court documents filed Friday, February 16th state that while Benefis may have been "negligent," they were not necessarily "willful." The 36-page document goes on to state the "Plaintiffs cite no legal authority to support inferring willful spoliation from the entire pattern of Benefis's mistakes in discovery." Documents conclude by stating in part, "Ultimately the court cannot say without indulging in speculation that the plaintiffs have been deprived of evidence that would have made their case better than it is now."


As we first reported on kfbb.com, the case surrounding Belt Football Player Robert Back and Benefis Health System was focused on the legal responsibility of Athletic Trainer Jessica Hansen, in the game that ultimately led to Back suffering a brain injury and becoming a quadriplegic.

A new legal battle is brewing over whether or not Benefis purposefully destroyed evidence.

To catch up on the timeline of this case: in September of 2014, Robert Back collapsed after halftime on the football field doctors later determined the full extent of his injuries as we know them today.

In July of 2015, attorneys alerted Benefis Health System that they were planning to file suit, and they should begin preserving all evidence.

The following March, the Back family did file suit, claiming negligence from several parties.

When Benefis was informed of the lawsuit, they were expected to keep and file all correspondence relating to the case. But now, attorneys for the Back family allege not only did Benefis not hand over important evidence, they destroyed it. And now there's an email to prove it.

The email in question is from September 11th, 2014, in which athletic trainer Jessica Hansen tells Belt football coach Jeff Graham, Robert Back is
ok to play concussion wise.

Despite the email coming from Hansen, a Benefis employee, Benefis never turned the email in as evidence. It wasn't until legal counsel for the Back family produced the email last year, with help from the Belt School District, that it came to light Hansen explicitly said Robert was okay to play from a concussion standpoint.

Court documents lay out Benefis' reasoning,  being that they only conducted a search limited to emails containing  Robert Back. Thats how the email slipped through the cracks. In turn, attorneys for Benefis are questioning the Back family saying if they knew about the email all along, why didn't *they bring it forward to submit as evidence?

And that's not all
Back's attorneys also claim there could be a number of unknown emails, texts, and messages regarding the events leading up to Back's injury, which now, we will never know.

As of December 2017, Back's attorneys are requesting sanctions against Benefis relating to the
Spoliation of Evidence.  Judge John Kutzman has yet to make a decision on those sanctions.  Trial is scheduled for March 5.


Correction, Jan. 15th, 2017: A previous version of this article stated Shannon Back produced the email in which Hansen stated Robert was “ok concussion wise.” While the details of the email and its discovery were outlined in Mrs. Back’s discovery response, Shannon Back herself never personally knew of or saw the email until it was presented by her legal counsel, with help from the Belt School District’s legal counsel.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Man run over by lawn mower while trying to kill son with chainsaw

    Man run over by lawn mower while trying to kill son with chainsaw

    Monday, October 15 2018 7:38 PM EDT2018-10-15 23:38:29 GMT

    BRISTOL, Tenn. (AP) - A man who police say was run over with a lawn mower while trying to kill his son with a chain saw has had to have his leg amputated. The Bristol Herald Courier reports that a warrant for 76-year-old Douglas Ferguson couldn’t be served until Tuesday because of the severity of his injuries.

    BRISTOL, Tenn. (AP) - A man who police say was run over with a lawn mower while trying to kill his son with a chain saw has had to have his leg amputated. The Bristol Herald Courier reports that a warrant for 76-year-old Douglas Ferguson couldn’t be served until Tuesday because of the severity of his injuries.

  • Man accused of inappropriately touching a girl under 12

    Man accused of inappropriately touching a girl under 12

    Monday, October 15 2018 6:18 PM EDT2018-10-15 22:18:40 GMT
    Monday, October 15 2018 6:18 PM EDT2018-10-15 22:18:40 GMT

    Joseph Francis Silva is charged with sexual intercourse without consent after a young girl spoke with police.

    Joseph Francis Silva is charged with sexual intercourse without consent after a young girl spoke with police.

  • BREAKING: Man found in Missouri River identified

    BREAKING: Man found in Missouri River identified

    Saturday, October 13 2018 12:43 PM EDT2018-10-13 16:43:59 GMT
    Tuesday, October 16 2018 12:38 PM EDT2018-10-16 16:38:21 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- The Cascade County Coroner has identified the man whose body was found in the Missouri River over the weekend.

    GREAT FALLS- The Cascade County Coroner has identified the man whose body was found in the Missouri River over the weekend.

  • Belt's Emily Langston Cheers and Drums to Support Huskies Sports Teams

    Belt's Emily Langston Cheers and Drums to Support Huskies Sports Teams

    Sunday, December 27 2015 7:50 PM EST2015-12-28 00:50:22 GMT
    Monday, December 28 2015 7:16 PM EST2015-12-29 00:16:48 GMT

    Sitting behind the drum set inside Belt's high school's band room, flipping her hair while she plays a beat, is junior percussionist Emily Langston. She's the only female drummer in the Belt pep band this year.

    Sitting behind the drum set inside Belt's high school's band room, flipping her hair while she plays a beat, is junior percussionist Emily Langston. She's the only female drummer in the Belt pep band this year.

  • Sheriff's Deputy accused of sexual contact with child

    Sheriff's Deputy accused of sexual contact with child

    Monday, October 15 2018 7:02 PM EDT2018-10-15 23:02:09 GMT
    Monday, October 15 2018 8:37 PM EDT2018-10-16 00:37:01 GMT

    According to the Glasgow Courier, the division of criminal investigation was contacted about the incident in May of this year.  The DCI identified the victim as a 17-year-old female. During the investigation, she told officials that she met the deputy back in 2014 during a traffic stop. The article said they had an intimate relationship for a year. They would contact via phone, email, and text to meet up for sexual encounters. The victim said most of the time when they met he wo...

    According to the Glasgow Courier, the division of criminal investigation was contacted about the incident in May of this year.  The DCI identified the victim as a 17-year-old female. During the investigation, she told officials that she met the deputy back in 2014 during a traffic stop. The article said they had an intimate relationship for a year. They would contact via phone, email, and text to meet up for sexual encounters. The victim said most of the time when they met he wo...

  • Warren DNA analysis points to Native American heritage; Trump denies offering $1M for test

    Warren DNA analysis points to Native American heritage; Trump denies offering $1M for test

    Monday, October 15 2018 1:38 PM EDT2018-10-15 17:38:55 GMT

    BOSTON - President Donald Trump is falsely denying that he offered $1 million for Sen. Elizabeth Warren to take a DNA test to prove whether she had Native American ancestors. Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, is a widely rumored 2020 presidential candidate.

    BOSTON - President Donald Trump is falsely denying that he offered $1 million for Sen. Elizabeth Warren to take a DNA test to prove whether she had Native American ancestors. Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, is a widely rumored 2020 presidential candidate.

  • Local band, L.A. bound

    Local band, L.A. bound

    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:49 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:49:44 GMT
    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:54 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:54:30 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- Five guys from Great Falls, one band, and a shot at recording in L.A. They're called Call Of The Awakened. They've been together since high school jamming out to hard rock and metal music, and now they're heading to L.A. in February for three weeks to record their second album. However, this journey didn't come easy. Besides the struggle of breaking into one of the toughest industries in the world, two members also dealt with major heartbreak.  "We were gettin...

    GREAT FALLS- Five guys from Great Falls, one band, and a shot at recording in L.A. They're called Call Of The Awakened. They've been together since high school jamming out to hard rock and metal music, and now they're heading to L.A. in February for three weeks to record their second album. However, this journey didn't come easy. Besides the struggle of breaking into one of the toughest industries in the world, two members also dealt with major heartbreak.  "We were gettin...

  • Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner resigns amid graphic baboon hunting photo controversy

    Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner resigns amid graphic baboon hunting photo controversy

    Monday, October 15 2018 6:29 PM EDT2018-10-15 22:29:39 GMT

    BOISE, Idaho - Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Blake Fischer has resigned, effective immediately, after photos involving a dead baboon family surfaced from an African hunting trip. Idaho Governor C.L. "Butch" Otter announced Monday afternoon that he asked for and received the resignation from Fischer, who was under intense criticism for the graphic photos from last month.

    BOISE, Idaho - Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Blake Fischer has resigned, effective immediately, after photos involving a dead baboon family surfaced from an African hunting trip. Idaho Governor C.L. "Butch" Otter announced Monday afternoon that he asked for and received the resignation from Fischer, who was under intense criticism for the graphic photos from last month.

  • NewsMore>>

  • Local band, L.A. bound

    Local band, L.A. bound

    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:49 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:49:44 GMT
    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:54 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:54:30 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- Five guys from Great Falls, one band, and a shot at recording in L.A. They're called Call Of The Awakened. They've been together since high school jamming out to hard rock and metal music, and now they're heading to L.A. in February for three weeks to record their second album. However, this journey didn't come easy. Besides the struggle of breaking into one of the toughest industries in the world, two members also dealt with major heartbreak.  "We were gettin...

    GREAT FALLS- Five guys from Great Falls, one band, and a shot at recording in L.A. They're called Call Of The Awakened. They've been together since high school jamming out to hard rock and metal music, and now they're heading to L.A. in February for three weeks to record their second album. However, this journey didn't come easy. Besides the struggle of breaking into one of the toughest industries in the world, two members also dealt with major heartbreak.  "We were gettin...

  • Bayern Brewery reaches out to Great Falls for glass recycling

    Bayern Brewery reaches out to Great Falls for glass recycling

    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:17 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:17:14 GMT
    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:22 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:22:40 GMT

    Jurgen Knoller, the CEO of Missoula's Bayern Brewing, leads the brewery's innovative recycling program and says he wants to start accepting glass from Great Falls.

    Jurgen Knoller, the CEO of Missoula's Bayern Brewing, leads the brewery's innovative recycling program and says he wants to start accepting glass from Great Falls.

  • HGTV 2019 Dream Home will be in Whitefish

    HGTV 2019 Dream Home will be in Whitefish

    Thursday, October 11 2018 5:01 PM EDT2018-10-11 21:01:18 GMT
    Thursday, October 11 2018 5:01 PM EDT2018-10-11 21:01:53 GMT

    Big news for HGTV fans... 2019's HGTV Dream Home has been announced, and it's being built right here in Montana. 

    Big news for HGTV fans... 2019's HGTV Dream Home has been announced, and it's being built right here in Montana. 

  • Man arrested for shoplifting and assaulting an employee at Albertsons

    Man arrested for shoplifting and assaulting an employee at Albertsons

    Monday, October 8 2018 11:53 PM EDT2018-10-09 03:53:48 GMT
    Tuesday, October 9 2018 12:36 AM EDT2018-10-09 04:36:38 GMT

    One man has been arrested for allegedly shoplifting and assaulting an employee at Albertsons.

    One man has been arrested for allegedly shoplifting and assaulting an employee at Albertsons.

  • The New Frontier: A Love Affair with Ag

    The New Frontier: A Love Affair with Ag

    Sunday, October 7 2018 6:13 PM EDT2018-10-07 22:13:40 GMT
    Monday, October 8 2018 12:24 AM EDT2018-10-08 04:24:02 GMT

    "Northern Ag Research Center has been a major part of my life for a lot of years." If it sounds like Mark Peterson is having a love affair with ag research, you're probably right. The Northern Ag Research Center has been around since 1915, but when Mark and his colleague, Gregg Carlson, began working more closely in the early 80's to expand the Center, things really started to take off. "He worked very, very well with a lot of people. If you see a lot of things here ...

    "Northern Ag Research Center has been a major part of my life for a lot of years." If it sounds like Mark Peterson is having a love affair with ag research, you're probably right. The Northern Ag Research Center has been around since 1915, but when Mark and his colleague, Gregg Carlson, began working more closely in the early 80's to expand the Center, things really started to take off. "He worked very, very well with a lot of people. If you see a lot of things here ...

  • Man taken into custody following Butte standoff

    Man taken into custody following Butte standoff

    Sunday, October 7 2018 10:32 PM EDT2018-10-08 02:32:25 GMT
    Sunday, October 7 2018 10:35 PM EDT2018-10-08 02:35:46 GMT
    Jason MittelstedterJason Mittelstedter

    A stand off between officers and an adult male fugitive lasted several hours Sunday, after the man barricaded himself inside a residence on the 400 Block of West Mercury Street.  According to  Butte-Silver Bow Sheriff Ed Lester, the man was eventually arrested and taken into custody. No one was injured. More information is expected to be released Monday. 

    A stand off between officers and an adult male fugitive lasted several hours Sunday, after the man barricaded himself inside a residence on the 400 Block of West Mercury Street.  According to  Butte-Silver Bow Sheriff Ed Lester, the man was eventually arrested and taken into custody. No one was injured. More information is expected to be released Monday. 

  • Vaughn Fire & Rescue Volunteer Fire Department honoring fallen firefighters

    Vaughn Fire & Rescue Volunteer Fire Department honoring fallen firefighters

    Sunday, October 7 2018 3:59 PM EDT2018-10-07 19:59:03 GMT
    Sunday, October 7 2018 4:03 PM EDT2018-10-07 20:03:13 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- Today you may have noticed fire department's around town having their flag at half-staff. This is because every first weekend of October firefighters across the United States ring a bell at 10 a.m. EST symbolizing those who've fallen while in the line of duty.  Every year all of the firefighter line of duty deaths are reported into Emmitsburg, Maryland where the National Fallen Firefighters Foundation Memorial Service is held. Vaughn Fire & Rescue Volunteer Fire...

    GREAT FALLS- Today you may have noticed fire department's around town having their flag at half-staff. This is because every first weekend of October firefighters across the United States ring a bell at 10 a.m. EST symbolizing those who've fallen while in the line of duty.  Every year all of the firefighter line of duty deaths are reported into Emmitsburg, Maryland where the National Fallen Firefighters Foundation Memorial Service is held. Vaughn Fire & Rescue Volunteer Fire...

  • 2nd Annual Caesar Showdown

    2nd Annual Caesar Showdown

    Saturday, October 6 2018 10:35 PM EDT2018-10-07 02:35:09 GMT
    Sunday, October 7 2018 12:10 PM EDT2018-10-07 16:10:01 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- The Do Bar will be hosting the Second Annual Great Falls Caesar Showdown October 6th, 2018. It starts at 3 p.m. and it's 10 dollars to get in the door. That'll include sampling Caesar’s from various restaurants in Great Falls. Do Bar said all proceeds will be donated to Casa-Can, our local non-profit child advocates.  Whose ever Caesar gets the most votes will win bragging rights, personal trophies, and what's looking like over a 200 cash pot.

    GREAT FALLS- The Do Bar will be hosting the Second Annual Great Falls Caesar Showdown October 6th, 2018. It starts at 3 p.m. and it's 10 dollars to get in the door. That'll include sampling Caesar’s from various restaurants in Great Falls. Do Bar said all proceeds will be donated to Casa-Can, our local non-profit child advocates.  Whose ever Caesar gets the most votes will win bragging rights, personal trophies, and what's looking like over a 200 cash pot.

Powered by Frankly

Features

  • More Features
  • Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 Cowles Montana Media. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.