Flu shot controversy: The danger vs. the benefit - ABC FOX Montana Local News, Weather, Sports KTMF | KWYB

Flu shot controversy: The danger vs. the benefit

Posted: Updated:

Flu shots will likely save thousands of lives this year.

They may also permanently paralyze people.

It’s a paradox that plays out every flu season, the need to vaccinate the masses at the expense of a few who will unexpectedly suffer irreparable injury from a bad reaction to the vaccine.

Lt Col. Tim Gardipee served 32 years in the army, in 20 countries and in five war zones.

"I had a busy life,” he says. “I had a business.  I was teaching soldiers.  I had a family.  I had lots."

But lots have changed since then.

"Being completely paralyzed from the neck down was quite a shock.  A startling shock.  Yes sir," says Gardipee.

It wasn't an IED or a bullet that took Lt. Col. Gardipee’s ability to walk.  It was a different kind of shot.

A standard flu shot that 123-million Americans get every year.

"you run a risk every time somebody sticks something in your body and challenges your immune system you can get a bad reaction," says Richard Gage.

Gage is one of the top vaccine injury attorneys in the country.  He says he's not anti-vaccine - - he has his own children vaccinated for measles, mumps, rubella and many other afflictions.  But not the flu.

"I see the bad reactions and what it does to people's lives and how it ruins people's lives," says Gage.

To put this into perspective the Centers for Disease Control estimates only one to two people per million doses gets a "severe reaction" from the flu shot - - anything from extreme fatigue to paralysis. That’s about 200 Americans every year.  It's enough for the industry to include paralysis as one of the risks on the package insert for the vaccine. 

Pam Whitney with the Missoula County Health Department says getting a flu shot isn't just for you, it's for those who can't get immunized.  It’s called herd immunity.  If most of us get immunized, the flu can't effectively spread to infants and others who can't get immunized.  You might think, I’d rather get the flu and not risk paralysis.  But Whitney says, “You'll be spreading it to the other people, who really can't protect themselves.  And it may kill an infant who gets Influenza."

And millions of American like Deputy Robert Parcell line up every year to get the flu shot without incident.

"It’s so rare,” says Parcell.  “And the chances of the flu causing you more problems are probably greater."

Lt. Col. Gardipee got the flu shot safely numerous times before he had a reaction. Medical professionals say there's no way of knowing who will have a reaction to the shot, but they stress that the risk is very low. If get the shot and get anything from fever to muscle pain to hives, you should notify your doctor.

Life may be harder now for Lt. Col Gardipee, but he says he still has a life.

"You are here for a purpose,” he says. “And my purpose is to teach others to carry on.  There’s rehab, there's a life worth living.

About 420 Americans file suit every year claiming they've been injured by flu shot. Patients win about half of those cases.  But their payout comes from taxes, not the pharmaceutical companies. The pharma companies can’t be sued.  Congress gave them immunity in 1986 setting up a special court after big pharma threatened to stop making vaccines because they were getting sued for vaccine injuries and they say, losing too much money.

We should stress, to put the odds of having a severe reaction to a flu shot into perspective, they are the same as being struck by lightning.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Name released of suspect in Missoula Northside shooting

    Name released of suspect in Missoula Northside shooting

    Thursday, September 20 2018 4:19 PM EDT2018-09-20 20:19:33 GMT

    MISSOULA - A 26-year-old man is in jail on charges related to a wreck and shooting on the Northside Thursday morning. 

    MISSOULA - A 26-year-old man is in jail on charges related to a wreck and shooting on the Northside Thursday morning. 

  • Lake County man charged with sexual assault of 4-year-old

    Lake County man charged with sexual assault of 4-year-old

    Friday, September 14 2018 4:41 PM EDT2018-09-14 20:41:44 GMT

    POLSON - Charging documents say a Lake County boy was airlifted to a Seattle hospital for treatment after the discovery of horrific abuse. Court documents say tribal officers responded to a home in Lake County on Aug. 24 after reports of severe abuse of a little boy. Witnesses said that the boy had a bed-wetting issue, and Keith Lee Michel, Jr., had been repeatedly taping the child's penis to stop him from urinating. A woman said she tried to stop MIchel from continuing th...

    POLSON - Charging documents say a Lake County boy was airlifted to a Seattle hospital for treatment after the discovery of horrific abuse. Court documents say tribal officers responded to a home in Lake County on Aug. 24 after reports of severe abuse of a little boy. Witnesses said that the boy had a bed-wetting issue, and Keith Lee Michel, Jr., had been repeatedly taping the child's penis to stop him from urinating. A woman said she tried to stop MIchel from continuing th...

  • Suspect in custody after shots fired, chase in Missoula Northside

    Suspect in custody after shots fired, chase in Missoula Northside

    Thursday, September 20 2018 8:54 AM EDT2018-09-20 12:54:28 GMT

    One man is in custody after an incident involving a gun and a short police chase in Missoula's Northside early Thursday morning. 

    One man is in custody after an incident involving a gun and a short police chase in Missoula's Northside early Thursday morning. 

  • Finally, indisputable proof: Bigfoot spotted in northern California

    Finally, indisputable proof: Bigfoot spotted in northern California

    Friday, January 9 2015 6:52 PM EST2015-01-09 23:52:03 GMT
    Saturday, January 10 2015 4:33 PM EST2015-01-10 21:33:06 GMT
    ROSEVILLE, Cali.- There is new, indisputable proof that Bigfoot exists, and has been spending most of his time in northern California. The footage was sent to a Paranormal group by a photographer/videographer who specializes in aerial videography using a quadcopter. A quadcopter is a drone that is lifted and propelled by 4 rotors.
    ROSEVILLE, Cali.- There is new, indisputable proof that Bigfoot exists, and has been spending most of his time in northern California. The footage was sent to a Paranormal group by a photographer/videographer who specializes in aerial videography using a quadcopter. A quadcopter is a drone that is lifted and propelled by 4 rotors.
  • Family asking for return of veteran's service dog Masik

    Family asking for return of veteran's service dog Masik

    Thursday, September 13 2018 12:04 PM EDT2018-09-13 16:04:31 GMT

    MISSOULA - A family is searching for their service dog, saying someone stole him from their truck while they parked at the Wye earlier this week. Masik the chow-chow belongs to Ryan Jones, a Marine who says he relies on the dog for helping with PTSD. 

    MISSOULA - A family is searching for their service dog, saying someone stole him from their truck while they parked at the Wye earlier this week. Masik the chow-chow belongs to Ryan Jones, a Marine who says he relies on the dog for helping with PTSD. 

  • Name released of suspect in trespassing at Old Faithful at Yellowstone

    Name released of suspect in trespassing at Old Faithful at Yellowstone

    Tuesday, September 18 2018 4:02 PM EDT2018-09-18 20:02:16 GMT

    A crowd watching Old Faithful in Yellowstone National Park was alarmed to see an adult man leave the boardwalk and stand on some of the park's most beloved - and dangerous - thermal features.

    A crowd watching Old Faithful in Yellowstone National Park was alarmed to see an adult man leave the boardwalk and stand on some of the park's most beloved - and dangerous - thermal features.

  • Yellowstone bull elk attacks man in new video

    Yellowstone bull elk attacks man in new video

    Friday, September 14 2018 12:43 PM EDT2018-09-14 16:43:33 GMT

    A newly released video captured the moment that a bull elk knocked over a man standing in his way at Yellowstone National Park.

    A newly released video captured the moment that a bull elk knocked over a man standing in his way at Yellowstone National Park.

  • Schools hike to support Philipsburg boy with MS

    Schools hike to support Philipsburg boy with MS

    Wednesday, September 19 2018 11:42 PM EDT2018-09-20 03:42:46 GMT
    Courtesy: Phillipsburg Public SchoolsCourtesy: Phillipsburg Public Schools

    Hundreds of school children took and a hike and a walk on Wednesday to raise funds for their classmate, 11-year-old Gus Fitz.

    Hundreds of school children took and a hike and a walk on Wednesday to raise funds for their classmate, 11-year-old Gus Fitz.

Powered by Frankly

Features

  • More Features
  • Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 Cowles Montana Media. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.