Attorney Explains How Privacy Law Could Interact With N.S.A. - ABC FOX MONTANA NEWS, WEATHER, SPORTS - KTMF/KWYB

Attorney Explains How Privacy Law Could Interact With N.S.A.

Posted: Updated:
BOZEMAN -

Over the summer, electronic privacy became a hot issue when National Security Agency employee Edward Snowden leaked documents exposing government collection of citizens cell phone data.

Montana was the first state to prohibit the government from collecting location data from your mobile device.

But since state lawmakers can only make state laws, and the U.S. Constitution has the supremacy clause, local lawyer Lindsey Beck isn't sure how this law will interact with federal agencies like the N.S.A.

"One thing that's for sure is Montana State local law enforcement agencies won't be able to use your cell phone to find out the location where you are," said Beck.

She said it could affect how state and federal agencies interact with each other.

"State law enforcement agencies might have a valid argument to say that we're not going to cooperate with these federal agencies, that they want Montana agents help using this kind of tracking information," said Beck. 

While Montana's current law only limits the government, House Bill 603's author, Daniel Zolnikov, originally wanted the law to apply to more than just the government.

"We wanted to basically obtain consent for the collection of your personal information," said Zolnikov. "And that's online, through departments, organizations, companies."

Many people already consent for companies like Google to track their location without even realizing it.

In September, Google Executive Chairman Eric Schmidt addressed the issue to reporters at the Economic Job Summit in Butte, saying Google only collects information if you say it is OK.

"We view for the location services, we give "opt in" and with "opt in" we think that's fine," said Schmidt.

Many users opt in to Google collecting your location data when you first download a Google app on your smart phone or tablet.

But if there an emergency, Google can track you location, even if you don't give them permission.

"The phone for example, for e- 911 services have to know where you are, unless you give us permission, we forget that information very quickly," Schmidt said.

911 is one of the exceptions to the Montana law.

Other exceptions include if you report it stolen, if you say the government can track your phone, or if there is an immediate life threatening situation.

Texas also passed a similar law earlier this year.

There, state and local governments must provide a search warrant before collecting people's emails.

Right now Senator Jon Tester is co-sponsoring a bill called the U.S.A. Freedom Act that will pull back the N.S.A., limiting them to only spy on specific terrorist suspects.

Congressman Steve Daines is sponsoring a house version of a similar bill.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Carlton Complex: 71% contained; 251,698 acres burned

    Carlton Complex: 71% contained; 251,698 acres burned

    Thursday, July 31 2014 2:22 PM EDT2014-07-31 18:22:03 GMT
    OKANOGAN COUNTY, Wash. - The Carlton Complex is now 71% contained and is 251,698 acres in size. Firefighters are continuing the hot, difficult work of “mopping up” and strengthening the fire line, especially in the areas south of Highway 20 towards the summit of Loop Loop.
    OKANOGAN COUNTY, Wash. - The Carlton Complex is now 71% contained and is 251,698 acres in size. Firefighters are continuing the hot, difficult work of “mopping up” and strengthening the fire line, especially in the areas south of Highway 20 towards the summit of Loop Loop.
  • Counterfeit One Dollar Bills in Butte

    Counterfeit One Dollar Bills in Butte

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 8:09 PM EDT2014-07-31 00:09:41 GMT
    Some people in Butte discover the money in their wallet is fake. Andrew Jackson, Ulysses S. Grant, Benjamin Franklin, those are the faces you usually see on counterfeit money but George Washington? Now, that's rare.
    Some people in Butte discover the money in their wallet is fake. Andrew Jackson, Ulysses S. Grant, Benjamin Franklin, those are the faces you usually see on counterfeit money but George Washington? Now, that's rare.
  • Man Charged With Felonies After Four-Hour Standoff

    Man Charged With Felonies After Four-Hour Standoff

    Thursday, July 31 2014 3:32 PM EDT2014-07-31 19:32:31 GMT
    A Columbia Falls man is in custody for two counts of felony theft and burglary after a four-hour standoff Wednesday.
    A Columbia Falls man is in custody for two counts of felony theft and burglary after a four-hour standoff Wednesday.
  • Many Frustrated By Stalled Cobell Settlements

    Many Frustrated By Stalled Cobell Settlements

    Wednesday, July 16 2014 9:30 PM EDT2014-07-17 01:30:30 GMT
    In Congress Wednesday, the group in charge of doling out Cobell settlement claims says it's waiting on setting exact amounts and a judge's okay before making the rest of the payments.
    In Congress Wednesday, the group in charge of doling out Cobell settlement claims says it's waiting on setting exact amounts and a judge's okay before making the rest of the payments.
  • Ancient Genome Sheds Light On Prehistoric Man

    Ancient Genome Sheds Light On Prehistoric Man

    Thursday, July 31 2014 12:31 AM EDT2014-07-31 04:31:21 GMT
    The remains of a young boy buried in southern Montana more than 12,000 years ago is shedding light on the history of prehistoric man.
    The remains of a young boy buried in southern Montana more than 12,000 years ago is shedding light on the history of prehistoric man.
  • Jimmy Shane, Team Oberto Wins Columbia Cup

    Jimmy Shane, Team Oberto Wins Columbia Cup

    Jimmy Shane in the U-6 Oberto boat wins the 49th HAPO Columbia Cup.
    Jimmy Shane in the U-6 Oberto boat wins the 49th HAPO Columbia Cup.
  • Zoo Town Open Disc Golf Tourney Brings Top Competition to Montana

    Zoo Town Open Disc Golf Tourney Brings Top Competition to Montana

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 12:23 AM EDT2014-07-29 04:23:46 GMT
    ABC/FOX Montana Sports Intern Cole Havens tells us about Disc Golf or 'Folf' as many people know it, is a sport that's becoming more and more popular in the Treasure State.
    ABC/FOX Montana Sports Intern Cole Havens tells us about Disc Golf or 'Folf' as many people know it, is a sport that's becoming more and more popular in the Treasure State.
  • ABC Montana Sports, 7-30-14

    ABC Montana Sports, 7-30-14

    Thursday, July 31 2014 12:15 AM EDT2014-07-31 04:15:24 GMT
    The Missoula Osprey host Great Falls as Justin Williams tried to set a new record for consecutive games with a hit. Highlights from the State A baseball tournament in Lewistown and the Bozeman soccer squad starts practicing.
    The Missoula Osprey host Great Falls as Justin Williams tried to set a new record for consecutive games with a hit. Highlights from the State A baseball tournament in Lewistown and the Bozeman soccer squad starts practicing.
Powered by WorldNow

Features

  • More Features
  • Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and Cowles Montana Media. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.