Dead End for Barry Beach - ABC FOX MONTANA NEWS, WEATHER, SPORTS - KTMF/KWYB

Dead End for Barry Beach

Posted: Updated:

After spending the last year and a half as a free man, convicted killer Barry Beach will be heading back to jail. The Montana Supreme Court issued the ruling late Tuesday afternoon in a 93-page document.

In a case with as many twists and turns as a winding Montana mountain pass, let's take a second to look at some of the key dates in this case before examining the Supreme Court's ruling. In 1979, officers found Kimberly Nees floating in a Poplar River.

In January of 1983 court documents say a young Barry Beach confessed to killing her, though the tapes recording that confession were later lost. One year later a jury convicted Beach of deliberate homicide and a judge sentenced him to serve 100 years without the possibility of parole.

Beach has appealed the decision several times, most recently in 2008 saying new witness testimony helped prove his innocence. That testimony was heard in a three-day hearing in 2011 when a district court judge ruled there was new evidence and Beach should get a new trial.

The state appealed and Tuesday Justice Jim Rice wrote in a 53-page decision that the district court judge who freed Beach listened to only the new evidence and did not consider the old evidence in his decision. Rice writes, "After reviewing all the evidence we conclude that Beach did not provide reliable evidence of his actual innocence." Justices Beth Baker, Laurie McKinnon, and District Judge Richard Simonton (who was sitting in place of Justice Mike McGrath) agreed.

Justice Brian Morris writes in a dissenting opinion that the District Court, not the Supreme Court, was in a better position to evaluate the new evidence and witness testimony. It appears the winding road that makes up this case has hit a dead end for Beach. Morris writes, "This ruling marks what likely will be the final chapter in the saga of Barry Beach."

We are told law enforcement will be asked to bring Beach back to jail.

  • Home: Butte/Bozeman NewsMore>>

  • MSU Ranks Among Top Advanced Tech Schools

    MSU Ranks Among Top Advanced Tech Schools

    Friday, August 1 2014 12:36 AM EDT2014-08-01 04:36:05 GMT
    Montana State University is listed as one of the top 50 advanced tech schools in the world by a recent study.
    Montana State University is listed as one of the top 50 advanced tech schools in the world by a recent study.
  • Bozeman Mayor Responds to Public Meeting's Abrupt End

    Bozeman Mayor Responds to Public Meeting's Abrupt End

    Friday, August 1 2014 12:31 AM EDT2014-08-01 04:31:42 GMT
    A public meeting in Bozeman Wednesday night, updating residents on efforts to mitigate violate organic compounds near the Story Mill Road landfill, ended abruptly after one man began shouting at the Mayor.
    A public meeting in Bozeman Wednesday night, updating residents on efforts to mitigate violate organic compounds near the Story Mill Road landfill, ended abruptly after one man began shouting at the Mayor.
  • Map Predicts Summer Heat in 2100 Based on Carbon Emissions

    Map Predicts Summer Heat in 2100 Based on Carbon Emissions

    Thursday, July 31 2014 8:15 PM EDT2014-08-01 00:15:05 GMT
    A new interactive map puts our heat into perspective by comparing current summer average temperatures to what scientists predict them to be in the year 2100.
    A new interactive map puts our heat into perspective by comparing current summer average temperatures to what scientists predict them to be in the year 2100.
  • NationalMore>>

  • Solid US job gains expected for 6th straight month

    Solid US job gains expected for 6th straight month

    Friday, August 1 2014 7:23 AM EDT2014-08-01 11:23:20 GMT
    With a host of reports this week pointing to a healthier U.S. economy, analysts expect Friday's monthly jobs report to send a similar message.
    With a host of reports this week pointing to a healthier U.S. economy, analysts expect Friday's monthly jobs report to send a similar message.
  • Witness in ex-Va. gov trial: Gifts, but no affair

    Witness in ex-Va. gov trial: Gifts, but no affair

    Friday, August 1 2014 5:43 AM EDT2014-08-01 09:43:05 GMT
    The key witness in the corruption trial of Virginia's former governor and his wife said his association with the couple was fraught with bad decisions - but an affair with the first lady was not one of them.
    The key witness in the corruption trial of Virginia's former governor and his wife said his association with the couple was fraught with bad decisions - but an affair with the first lady was not one of them.
  • Florida preserve brings wolves, people together

    Florida preserve brings wolves, people together

    Friday, August 1 2014 4:52 AM EDT2014-08-01 08:52:05 GMT
    At Seacrest Wolf Preserve in northern Florida, billed as the largest such facility in the Southeast, owners Cynthia and Wayne Watkins say they raise their wolves to become accustomed to humans - and for a $25 fee,...
    At Seacrest Wolf Preserve in northern Florida, billed as the largest such facility in the Southeast, owners Cynthia and Wayne Watkins say they raise their wolves to become accustomed to humans - and for a $25 fee, they...
  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • ABC All-Stars: BSHS Softball Players Redemption

    ABC All-Stars: BSHS Softball Players Redemption

    Thursday, July 31 2014 8:16 PM EDT2014-08-01 00:16:08 GMT
    After a heartbreaking loss in the State AA Championship game, a core group of girls from Big Sky High School have stayed positive in their road to redemption.
    After a heartbreaking loss in the State AA Championship game, a core group of girls from Big Sky High School have stayed positive in their road to redemption.
  • LOOK: Faces Of WA State's Missing People

    LOOK: Faces Of WA State's Missing People

    Thursday, February 27 2014 11:49 AM EST2014-02-27 16:49:33 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - The missing persons listed in this slideshow resided in the state of Washington at the time of their disappearance or may have traveled to Washington State. These pictures came from Washington State Patrol's website. If you have any information about any of these missing people call 1-800-543-5678.
    SPOKANE, Wash. - The missing persons listed in this slideshow resided in the state of Washington at the time of their disappearance or may have traveled to Washington State. These pictures came from Washington State Patrol's website. If you have any information about any of these missing people call 1-800-543-5678.
  • Big Dipper Plans New Parlor In Billings

    Big Dipper Plans New Parlor In Billings

    Friday, August 1 2014 12:27 AM EDT2014-08-01 04:27:24 GMT
    The Big Dipper plans a new parlor in Billings.
    The Big Dipper plans a new parlor in Billings.
  • Many Frustrated By Stalled Cobell Settlements

    Many Frustrated By Stalled Cobell Settlements

    Wednesday, July 16 2014 9:30 PM EDT2014-07-17 01:30:30 GMT
    In Congress Wednesday, the group in charge of doling out Cobell settlement claims says it's waiting on setting exact amounts and a judge's okay before making the rest of the payments.
    In Congress Wednesday, the group in charge of doling out Cobell settlement claims says it's waiting on setting exact amounts and a judge's okay before making the rest of the payments.
  • Bozeman Mayor Responds to Public Meeting's Abrupt End

    Bozeman Mayor Responds to Public Meeting's Abrupt End

    Friday, August 1 2014 12:31 AM EDT2014-08-01 04:31:42 GMT
    A public meeting in Bozeman Wednesday night, updating residents on efforts to mitigate violate organic compounds near the Story Mill Road landfill, ended abruptly after one man began shouting at the Mayor.
    A public meeting in Bozeman Wednesday night, updating residents on efforts to mitigate violate organic compounds near the Story Mill Road landfill, ended abruptly after one man began shouting at the Mayor.
  • Missoula Business Finds Niche in Treehouses

    Missoula Business Finds Niche in Treehouses

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 4:24 PM EDT2014-07-30 20:24:43 GMT
    For most of us, being able to walk out your back door and take off flying around your backyard, finally coming to a rest high in the trees-- only exists in our imagination.
    For most of us, being able to walk out your back door and take off flying around your backyard, finally coming to a rest high in the trees-- only exists in our imagination.
  • Counterfeit One Dollar Bills in Butte

    Counterfeit One Dollar Bills in Butte

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 8:09 PM EDT2014-07-31 00:09:41 GMT
    Some people in Butte discover the money in their wallet is fake. Andrew Jackson, Ulysses S. Grant, Benjamin Franklin, those are the faces you usually see on counterfeit money but George Washington? Now, that's rare.
    Some people in Butte discover the money in their wallet is fake. Andrew Jackson, Ulysses S. Grant, Benjamin Franklin, those are the faces you usually see on counterfeit money but George Washington? Now, that's rare.
  • MHP Increases Patrols For Testicle Festival

    MHP Increases Patrols For Testicle Festival

    Thursday, July 31 2014 6:41 PM EDT2014-07-31 22:41:38 GMT
    The 33rd annual Testicle Festival is underway, and officers are bringing in the reinforcements to prevent DUI's.
    The 33rd annual Testicle Festival is underway, and officers are bringing in the reinforcements to prevent DUI's.
Powered by WorldNow

Features

  • More Features
  • Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and Cowles Montana Media. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.